Two Ways to Count an Empty Shop: Why Saint-Roch Has Two Vacancy Figures

One district, two municipal measures, and a target written in the one that was dropped.

Rue Saint-Joseph in Saint-Roch, photographed on 15 October 2022. This photograph is from 2022 and is not evidence of any vacancy or inoccupation rate reported here. Photo: Wilfredor / Wikimedia Commons, CC0; cropped top and bottom and resized.
JB
By
James Bennett - Food, Hotels & City Life Writer
8 Min Read

Two numbers describe empty shopfronts in Saint-Roch, and both come from the City of Québec. One is 9.1%, reported this week by a newspaper that asked for it. The other is 17.8%, and it sits in the City’s own action plan. They have not appeared side by side anywhere we can find.

They are not a contradiction. They are not a trend either. The gap between them is a definition, and the City changed which one it uses.

The figure published this week

Le Journal de Québec reported on 11 November, in a piece signed Taïeb Moalla, that the SDC St-Roch district has the worst rate of unoccupied premises in the city. The measure counts only businesses at street level. It moved from 7.1% to 9.1% between October 2025 and June 2026.

The paper was careful about where the numbers came from: they were obtained by Le Journal rather than published. By the same report, a balanced market sits between 3% and 5%, which puts this district at close to double the upper bound. Rue du Campanile in Sainte-Foy is second at 4.8%. Five sectors are at 0%: the SDC 3e Avenue, rue Notre-Dame, rue Racine, avenue Royale and chemin Sainte-Foy.

The figure the City published last year

The City’s own action plan for Saint-Roch is a public document, and it carries a different figure. In the brochure the City publishes, the ground-floor commercial vacancy rate in the SDC St-Roch sector reached 17.8% in July 2025, on a trend the plan itself calls rising.

That ranked the district fourth among the nine commercial streets inside SDC districts for empty premises. The same plan describes this sector as having the highest density of shops and services in the city. Both statements are in the same brochure, a page apart.

Why those two numbers are not a line

The City uses two yardsticks and they count different things. A taux de vacance is the ratio of vacant business premises, whether or not they are offered on the market. A taux d’inoccupation is the proportion offered on the market and available to rent.

The difference is every unit that stands empty without a sign in the window. Those count in the first measure and not in the second, which is why the first produces a bigger number on the same street in the same month.

So the plan’s 17.8% and this week’s 9.1% can both be accurate and still describe different populations. What they cannot be is two points on one line. The only comparison in hand that stays inside a single series is 7.1% to 9.1%, a rise of 2.0 percentage points across eight months, and that one is sound.

The switch also explains something that puzzled people in June. Councillor Elainie Lepage spoke then of a rate that had fallen from 19% to 16% here. That calculation, Le Journal reports, is no longer the one being used.

The plan still sets its target in the measure that was dropped

Objective 2 of the current action plan is to support commercial vitality by reducing the taux de vacance. The plan runs to 2029. Its Action 5 promises a diagnostic of vacant or requalifiable spaces.

The City gave a reason for preferring the newer yardstick: it says the measure gives a more precise idea of how alive a shopping street is. That is a defensible argument, and this article does not suggest the change was made to flatter anyone. It does leave a practical question open. If the target is written in one measure and the reporting now arrives in another, what is the plan’s progress going to be judged against?

The same word, two other meanings, in the same brochure

Anyone reading the plan and the newspaper together has a further trap to avoid. The word inoccupation already appears twice in the brochure, each time about something else.

It appears for offices: Saint-Roch holds 45 professional buildings, 14% of the city’s office stock, four million square feet, with a rate of 21% against a municipal average of 12%, credited to a study by Groupe Altus. It appears again for rental housing, at 2.7% across Limoilou, Saint-Roch and Saint-Sauveur. Neither figure is about shops, and neither belongs in a sentence about storefronts.

What the City says it has done

The councillor for the district declined an interview with Le Journal, and a written statement came from the mayor’s office instead. That statement from the mayor’s office says 1.3 million dollars went into attracting new businesses and supporting tenant improvements over the past year, and that the fund assisted 25 businesses, five of them new.

The director general of the SDC St-Roch told the paper she was unavailable to comment. Two days before the report, the Marchand administration had been promoting its five-year record on commercial streets.

The underlying data is not public here. In Montréal it is.

We searched the provincial open-data portal for the series behind these rates. Under the City of Québec, queries for either French term return nothing at all.

The City of Montréal, on the same portal, publishes Locaux commerciaux et statuts d’occupation, a field survey of commercial units and their occupancy status across its agglomeration. One city releases the premises-by-premises record. The other released a single rate to one newsroom that asked.

That is not an accusation of secrecy. It is a description of what a resident of Saint-Roch can check for themselves today, which is nothing, and what a resident of Montréal can, which is the whole file.

What we are asking next

Three questions follow, and none of them is answered by what is published. When was the yardstick changed, and by whom? Is the older series still being collected, so that the plan’s own target can be measured to 2029? And what do the two series say for the same month, side by side?

For context on the district itself, our guide to Québec City’s neighbourhoods places Saint-Roch among them, our account of the city’s technology economy covers the firms that took its office space, and our profile of Vanier describes another dense francophone working-class district nearby. Our guide to the Simons stores covers the city’s home-grown department store.

This piece is deliberately narrow. It makes no claim about why shops in Saint-Roch are empty, which is a different and harder story, and it does not treat the different rates now circulating about this district as one picture. We will report what the City answers.

Share This Article
JB
Food, Hotels & City Life Writer
James shares recommendations for restaurants, accommodations and experiences that capture the energy of Québec City.
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *